Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Insecurity is the heart of racism

When Subang Jaya State Assemblywoman Hannah Yeoh and her husband Ramachandran Muniandy decided to register their newborn daughter as “anak Malaysia”, nobody told them that it would unearth deep-seated insecurity in Malaysians’ attitudes towards race.

Hannah believes that there is a sizeable amount of Malaysians who – like her – prefer to be identified as Malaysian and not ethnic Chinese, Indian or Malay.

However, she was shocked by some of the reactions she got when she tried to get the National Registration Department to officially recognize the concept of Bangsa Malaysia. “Someone told me I was ‘not a submissive wife’, while others accused me of being anti-Indian.”

While awareness of the Bangsa Malaysia concept is growing, Hannah says that her recent experience has revealed that a segment of the population is resistant towards it. “Some people condemn political parties for having racist agendas, but they are not able to let go of the notion of race either.”

Hannah traces this attitude on the system of racial labeling which has become a ‘stronghold’ in the way this country functions.

“Race is at the core of each Malaysian’s identity from the moment they are born. Everything revolves around which category you tick in the box for ‘race’ in Malaysia,” the former lawyer told The Rocket.

Hannah points out that a Malaysian going overseas who describe themselves as being ‘chinese’ would find themselves being mistaken for being a China national.

Asked what would make Bangsa Malaysia a reality, she replied that Malaysians must abandon the argument of race.

“Our sense of security in our identity must not be rooted in skin color. It comes from knowing who you are… your relationship with your Maker and your loved ones… being empowered by that. I don’t believe I depend on my skin color for anything,” stressed Hannah.

The first-term state assemblywoman firmly believes that insecurity is at the heart of racism. “Insecurity turns people into racists. But unity can happen when the people of this land feel a sense of belonging, when we look at the things that unite us and not focus on skin color.”

Describing an example of unity, she relates the story of two best friends and former schoolmates, which she calls a tale of “the real 1 Malaysia”. Wheelchair-bound Chin Kit is best friends with Azizul. Despite living in Pantai Dalam, Azizul would travel all the way to USJ 1 in Subang Jaya just to spend time with Chin Kit.

They hang out together and often share a taxi to go shopping. Azizul, who suffers a disability to his hand, would carry Chin Kit in and out of his heavy wheelchair.

“In a country with no natural disasters, we often take unity for granted. But these two friends with disabilities had to depend on each other for survival. There is no room for discrimination when we need to depend on each other,” Hannah added.

“Don’t be an Ibrahim Ali at your dinner table”

Quoting blogger Nathaniel Tan, Hannah exhorted parents to be mindful of their choice of words when speaking about those of other races. “Don’t be an Ibrahim Ali at the dinner table, your children will easily pick up stereotypes,” she said.

Hannah believes that leadership is the key to breaking racial stereotypes. She added that Bangsa Malaysia would not happen if teachers continue to be trained by Biro Tata Negara, or if political parties are race-based.

She rapped Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak for spending millions on branding to promote the 1 Malaysia concept “without sincerity”, and not living up to expectations. Hannah said that the slogan is without substance if the Prime Minister does not take action against incidents of racial intolerance.

For instance inflammatory remarks by Perkasa president Ibrahim Ali; or the recent 8TV Ramadan Public Service Announcement Advertisements – which she describes as “tasteless and condescending”.

Hannah warned against an attitude of “sweeping things under the carpet”, as over time, the accumulated sensitivity will explode. She supports DAP National Chairman Karpal Singh’s suggestion of legislating a Race Relations Act.

The 32-year-old says that she always strives to emphasize inclusiveness in constituency allocations and programmes organised by her kawasan. “For instance, in the Subang Jaya Talent Quest competition, we required group participants to be multicultural and not just made up of members of the same race,” she said.

Hannah – also known as Yeoh Tseow Suan – decried that mono-racial friendship has become second nature in an increasingly polarised society. She described the phenomenon of adults gradually having fewer friends of different races as being “unhealthy”.

By nurturing the things that unite Malaysians, she hopes to rekindle multicultural friendships – in particular for her daughter’s generation. -The Rocket


Joshua Lopez said...

In this time and age, one is expected to be a 'submissive wife?' What sort of Draconian Feudalism is this? I believe that Racism comes from insecurity yes & the sense of feeling one's race being attacked or being looked down upon is felt by those who suffer an inferiority complex.

Yes, many Indians still regard themselves as being from India and Not Malaysia first. I find it rather troubling and highly frustrating.

Anonymous said...

Well said, YB Hannah !

There are no biological "races",
only differences in gene frequencies.
And amongst different groups of people following difference customs (ethnic groups).

"Race" is socially constructed.
Otherwise, why are there "Coloureds" in South Africa but not in the USA;
why is Obama considered a "black" when his mother is "white"; why
Mahathir is a "Malay" (he even admits that he is a "constitutional Malay") ?

Phua Kai Lit

Bernard Choo said...

I say 'yes'to the ending of race-based politics in Malaysia. The Government will win many hearts if they start the ball rolling by deleting race-based details in our birth certificates

Anonymous said...

I do advocate Bangsa Malaysia. However, the coalition that you are representing is not any better.

Anwar is still a racist. You agree not?

Anonymous said...

More than a month has passed and yet nothing has been done. The operators are still happily operating on right under the nose of the law enforcement officers and councillors. What kind of world are we living in??

Dear YB,
Pls do something abt those illegal cyber cafes at Jalan PJS 7/18 Bandar Sunway. Those shop lots next to the 7Eleven outlet. They have been operating 24/7 for quite sometime. These illegal activities are operating right under the nose of the enforcement authorities and the councillors. This is a residential area and such illegal and unhealthy activities should be wiped out immediately. Pls act fast. TQ YB.

Joshua Lopez said...

Anwar was very racist as DPM which made me a victim of having to go to school during Christmas!

But i strongly believe that this Man has changed bcos God gave him a good taste of his own medicine. Prison, Suffering, Torments, Curses & Blows have moulded him into a repented good man.

At the end of the day our desire for change should not be centred on Anwar. Anwar is just a mode for us to get a brand new government. Period.

Anonymous said...

I support your bangsa malaysia concept, but I do hope that doesnt mean we forgo our heritage.

Also, when requiring group participants to be "multicultural" and not just made up of members of the same race, doesnt that label people according to their race as well?

Can't participants participate as bangsa malaysia and not be rejected just because too many of them are participating already?

Joshua Lopez said...

Heritage & Race is For History. Now Lets Move On To Bigger Things that matter more such as Nation Building, Human Rights & minimizing corruption.

This Christmas, I Pray For A New Government.

Anonymous said...

I applaud you for making the point loud and clear to fellow Malaysian.

However, I do not believe Bangsa Malaysia is the solution. A bigot will find another excuse to bigot about even after you perform plastic surgery to all Malaysian to look like malay, even after everyone only speak fluent malay, even after successfully converted everyone into islam, even after everyone earn exactly the same salary, even ……

I am a Chinese. I love my Chinese root and will identify myself as a Malaysian Chinese with NO APOLOGY. Synthesizing a worthwhile new culture from the old roots takes a lot of ingenuity, sincerity and time (in the scale of centuries). This is especially true in Malaysia where cultures as sophisticated as Chinese, Indian, Arab and western European co-exist. Bangsa Malaysia project is, in my view, too na├»ve and lacks the necessary depth for full cultural integration. It is the result of the fast food mentality that gives us Proton. Don’t take shortcut when it comes to education, religious harmony and racial integration, because it never works.